Waking Up to the Psychological Impacts of our Climate Crisis
by Roger Herried
The above image is an introduction to the psychological impacts of climate change faced by a growing number of us. The past year has set off many climate-related alarm bells due to wildfires and extreme weather. After decades of exposure to its corrosive mental effects, experts, activists, and the public are experiencing increased levels of trauma. This presentation will walk you through the mental implications and resources currently available. Our established institutions, especially the media, have failed to help us deal with the climate crisis. We are on our own for now.
This story was written based on a review of almost 1,000 December 2019 climate articles. Less than ten of the stories mentioned the subject of psychological impacts. Please share this with anyone you know who is expressing fears about the climate crisis. You might help save their life. I still have my college textbook about “global warming” before working at Greenpeace in the 1970s. My first experience with the impacts of climate on our mental stability came during a national green party conference in the mid-1980s. I was shocked as a climate scientist fell apart mentally when the group failed to make climate the top issue. A list of articles referenced in this work is at the bottom of this piece.
In this recent article, a therapist set up an iconic Peanut’s booth known as The Doctor is In at a local public venue. She found that nearly 60% of those who visited the booth were worried about climate change. According to a psychologist in the same piece, 100% of the western world is impacted. An excellent example of this kind of avoidance appeared in this Australian wildfire article where the author blames public apathy!
A family member, who has never expressed concerns about the climate issue, sent me a recent Washington Post story about the Santa Barbara wildfires. The article mentioned a freak 3-hour heatwave on July 6th, 2018. Temperatures jumped 25 degrees late in the afternoon to 115 degrees, killing innumerable animals in the area. The article also highlighted the fact that Santa Barbara, the home of the environmental movement’s Earth Day, has failed to meet its climate goals under pressure from the local business community because of America’s entrenched lifestyles. The Post’s narrow and sensationalist format here fails to mention either the ten-fold increase of global wildfires since 2001 or Australia’s horrific fire season. Furthermore, the Post didn’t promote their own poll that 46% of Americans want the country to stop using fossil fuels!
Check out this article for a broader review of mental impacts on the general public. For the best overview, you will want to download this important mental health guide by the American Psychological Association. As climate-related events grow, we can expect more people to experience Solastalgia (you probably have this), PTSD, and other symptoms. Our human frailties must be confronted individually and by society. For those of us who acknowledge that we are part of the natural world, some are reaching out to Eco-psychologists for help. Other people dealing with their trauma are turning to activism, meditation, or spiritual activities.
One of America’s biggest problems is how we stigmatize mental illness, and its correlative, mental health. Many of us, especially men, use avoidance as a solution. The Association of Psychological Science estimates that 60 million Americans suffer some form of mental illness annually, and 40% use avoidance to deal with it. Doesn’t this sound a lot like the root cause of the climate denial issue? Climate activists who deal with communication should be aware of The National Alliance for Mental Illness’ 9 major steps to help deal with stigma. Nor can the mental health impacts resulting from the corporate media be overstated. Their manipulative advertising techniques and promotion of stigma are legendary. Last but not least should be a look at how politicians and social media are using neurotic profiling.
Personal and Societal Lifestyle Changes
As this recent BBC story points out, this is no longer about minor changes of comfort or getting a slightly more fuel-efficient car. This Mother Jones investigative piece points out, (note I’m not in agreement on their nuclear posture) make a stab at what it will take. There suggestion for a WW II R&D budget, suggesting that using more energy is just fine — just don’t use fossil fuels. How this plays out globally with consumption nightmares wasn’t tackled however. The most populated regions are heading for a full-scale train-wreck that demands serious shifts in how energy, food, and water are consumed. Many parts of the world are already in crisis from unhealthy air and water due primarily to the unsustainable exponential growth in the human population.
Our individual lifestyle choices have dramatic impacts on the planet when multiplied across our culture. Many online models lay out the broad array of lifestyle changes that people can begin to work on. The simple living movement takes is still an appropriate place to investigate lifestyle changes with this list of 100 simple living blogs.
One of the best tools to evaluate your carbon footprint is this carbon calculator.
The corporate agenda of framing frugality as a cardinal sin needs to stop. Look how “comfort (junk) foods” are now called when they are the most damaging to not just our health but to the planet’s.
Most simple living values imply going rural or living in cooperative communities. This is a norm for much of the rural world, but alien to Americans. This decades’ old movement dates back to the Amish culture, the sixties’ back to the land, or tiny house movements. For urbanites trapped in high consumption lifestyles, it all boils down to major systemic changes. For example, America’s middle class consumes three times more energy than India’s. Much of the problem is embedded not just in our cars and electricity, but also in our food. Infrastructures based on sprawl will collapse economically over time. People trapped in this lifestyle should seek out cooperative values and community-oriented actions that focus on alternative housing and transit decisions. If this sounds like gibberish, spend some time going through the above materials.
The Lucy booth presentation also looks at the political demographics. This includes the primary denial group in charge of the system, the wealthy, well-educated white men. The toughest question is whether we can flip their denial. Many strategists say that the 2020 election is the most important ever, giving us nine months to do this. We have a long way to go to address the main problems of global consumption, the planet’s carrying capacity, fossil fuels, water, agriculture, and dead soils.
There are hopeful signs of change all around us. For example, the TED Talk video by a billionaire titled Beware, fellow plutocrats, the pitchforks are coming* in which, Nick Hanauer makes the case that our trickle-down economics is destroying the country. He believes that a vibrant middle class is a critical foundation for a stable society. The biggest danger he sees is the economic injustice orchestrated by the wealthy elite. Some of his ideas are weak, but his warning that pitchforks will come if plutocrats don’t change is important. This goes for the climate deniers as well. By contrast, the New Yorker just documented how many super-rich people are building doomer bunkers.
There are No Issues Left Except the Corporate Media
The the media is the main obstacle to the climate crisis in the U.S.next to the fossil fuel industry.
The media should be pressuring climate deniers, not giving them a platform. They are directly culpable for the failure to act on climate change. Some segments of the media are doing better but not the big 5 TV Networks. These networks are where 60% of Americans get their news. As mentioned above, with the Washington Post, the major daily newspapers are hardly doing better. Thanks to Rupert Murdoch, the Koch brothers, and Fox News, the evangelical right-wing has become climate deniers. Besides TV broadcasters’ fake balancing act, they are intentionally downplaying the Green New Deal, the popular campaign proposal for taxing stock market transactions, and stopping capital flight. Only one out of 55 climate news stories in a day came from a major broadcaster. Activists concerned about the climate crisis must take a new approach to the media. The media must stop using sensationalist coverage and give more weight to scientists. They need to speak out about Fox’s lying and denial. Finally, the media must include a global perspective that includes the demands of the movement.
The fossil-fuel divestment movement is one area of positive news. The biggest story is Goldman-Sachs decision to no longer fund coal development. Then BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, joined the Climate+100 group. This group controls $41 trillion in assets, calling for sustainable alternatives to fossil fuels. In 2018, global coal growth (map) leveled off for the first time. The fossil fuel industry has created its own Iron Triangle as denier’s like Trump and rail companies continue their stonewalling. So, for now, all resistance is at the state or local level.
Meanwhile, a Silicon Valley think tank called “Singularity University” has been promoting the concept of disruptive technologies and exponential thinking. This concept of exponential growth and how quickly societal change can take place is worth a closer look.
What is Exponential Versus Linear Thinking
and Can it Make a Difference?
As individuals, our brain merges all of our activities, senses, and thoughts into a single stream of linear consciousness. Individuals are not good at multitasking, but this is not the case when it comes to our collective existence. Important changes can spread exponentially through society. A good example of exponential change was the development (or the) expansion of the ozone hole with the world quickly phasing out Freon worldwide. But the Ozone hole will take fifty years to heal and still plays a role in climate disruption.
Understanding how social change works has been around for decades. Bill Moyer first devised this social change model known as the Movement Action Plan. Exponential growth can occur in a variety of ways. Whether it’s around economics, physics, cultural phenomena, or climate impacts, too few of us understand exponential change. A great example of this is Al Bartlet’s Arithmetic, Population and Energy — and the exponential function. * In this must-see video, Bartlett documents the frightening exponential growth of coal.
Another variation of exponential phenomena is the domino effect, as demonstrated at the beginning of this video on climate change. While Stanford’s Tony Seba’s video * shows how exponential strategies can impact transportation and climate. The most powerful example in his video is demonstrated by how quickly society moved from the horse and buggy era to the car.
It is our potential for exponential change that is the best hope we will survive the climate crisis.
The Harder They Come, The Harder They Fall
The climate community needs a triage based response about how it targets specific audiences. Western Civilization needs a full stop reverse course process put in place, but that is not what we are seeing. Some climate activists call this degrowth.
There is a split between most climate activists and institutional researchers about how to reverse climate denial. This split was evident at the recent COP event in Spain. The biggest problem, however, is how to communicate with deniers or key stakeholders, like the fossil fuel industry. Psychologists and social scientists are now weighing in on how to communicate with climate deniers. Social scientists have proposed the following ten principles of good communication. Climate experts like Per Espen Stoknes, who acknowledge apocalyptic fatigue, are calling for better strategies.
After 40 years of climate campaigns, Eco-psychologists are now treating traumatized activists. Madrid’s COP-25 gathering has been described as a near failure, even though UN leaders warned that we are reaching a point of no return. So, have we reached the climate and human inflection point yet? Australia’s wildfires, the worst ever, could very well be it.
Just Don’t Stand There! Do Something!
One of the most important solutions to climate despair is doing something about it. The most important, of course, is to talk about the issue regularly and bring it up with your family and friends. Please see the lifestyle section for more.
Climate Caroling In Your Neighborhood
Go take a walk just before bedtime. See how many of your neighbors are leaving lights on. You might just be surprised if not shocked to see how many lights people are leaving on all night, especially outside lighting. You can do something about people’s behavior, even those that think the climate is a non-issue. You can put together a friendly flyer and put it in their mailbox, or on their steps suggesting that they can actually still retain their sense of security and safety while saving money and our climate.
Go out and be a neighborhood climate activist. The flyer should include information about motion sensor light bulbs and where to get them. These light-bulbs will turn on or off when anyone is within ten feet (products vary). The bulbs are not cheap (they are cheaper on Amazon) but will soon pay for themselves. Inside lights, can also be replaced with inexpensive LED nightlights. If you know a concerned neighbor, put some songs together and go out and sing them at people’s doors. “Tis the season to save the climate.” Keep track of how many neighbors respond. Take the idea to your city representatives and urge them to fund a serious campaign. Assume that most people who leave their lights on at night are not just conservative but also frightened about security. Focus on this with only a minor accent on climate.
Not too long ago, a Dene elder was taken to a spot overlooking the city of Los Angeles. Shocked by what he saw, he realized at that moment why his people’s lands were being exploited by mining. Humans, as do other animals, have the capacity for caring until it’s beaten out of them. This is one battle that humanity can’t afford to lose. The global community wants to change! Overcoming inertia, and the allies, and profiteers of the fossil fuel industry are the challenges.
Will it be Australia that finally wakes the world up? We are not there yet, as a recent poll found that only a few are willing to accept a $1 a month tax. This crisis is about the media’s failure to inform people worldwide. Have you ever seen a major network do a prime time TV program on reversing climate change? Their climate coverage tactics are responsible for people’s growing psychological impacts.
Very few people fully understand the role media’s plays in climate change. Not a single major network has ever shown the BBC’s “Century of the Self” documentary about the media’s role in manipulating us. We desperately need a new era of media literacy now that Chomsky or McLuhan have long become outmoded by social media and promotion of the Internet Of Things.
For the original article including the extensive links:
Stop Big Ag from poisoning our food system
The next president needs to act on factory farming
Keep toxic sludge out of our water
Call on Lowe’s and on Depot to stop selling glyphosate products
Read how people are combatting climate change at theEarthjustice newsletter
Read about space and the ozone layer
Italian cancer victim wins case against 5-G technology
Peru is protecting Machu Picchu by planting one million trees to guard against mudslides and fires.
Protests continue in France against pension “reform” as activists are joined by teachers’ unions, doctors, lawyers, and railway workers.
Wombats in Australian fire-affected areas not only allow other animals to shelter in their deep, fire-resistant burrows, but actively herd other animals into them.
Music above all things: Scientists discover that playing normal coral reef sounds brings dead corals back to life.
Massive victory as BlackRock CEO promises to center climate change in investment strategy.
Harvard Law School students disrupt recruitment event, calling on major law firm to #DropExxon.
The international Communications University is born.
Atlantic Coast Pipeline loses permit battle with historically black community.
St. Louis prosecutor sues police union under KKK law for racist practices.
Climate groups thank Sanders for being only candidate at debate to stand against Trump-led trade deal.
Schumer praised for joining Sanders in voting against Trump trade deal that ignores climate crisis.
Richmond, California bans coal, blocking key export route to Asia.
House to consider Lee and Khanna-backed measures to stop Trump’s march to war with Iran.
Minneapolis joins with 90 U.S. cities to say US troops out of Iraq — no war on Iran.
House Democrats demand ICE release transgender detainees: “not one more life should be lost.”
House Democrats open investigation into inhuman Trump policy forcing asylum seekers to Mexico.
Jorge Garcia, Michigan dad deported after 30 years in US, wins fight to return home.
House votes to protect scammed students, and blocks DeVos.
House Committee holds hearing about cannabis policies for the next decade.
Two-thirds of people in the U.S. want to tax the rich.
Nearly all Americans want to get off fossil fuels (but will the media tell it like it is?)
Treasury opens investigation tax break for poor being exploited by rich, including Kushner family.
Seattle bans foreign-influenced corporations from political spending in local elections.
Federal civil rights office to investigate detention and questioning of Iranian Americans at border.
Senator Harris calls for halt to GOP nominations of judges during impeachment. GOP complies.
Federal judge blocks Trump order allowing localities to refuse new refugees.
New Illinois law clears way for undocumented and transgender students to access state financial aid.
Rep. Elijah Cummings wanted $1 million in reelection funds sent to youth programs after his death.
Citing threat from armed groups, Virginia governor declares emergency and bans guns at state capitol.
Women no longer 3/5 of person as Virginia becomes 38th state to ratify the ERA, nearly 100 years after women activists endured force feeding to advocate e for women getting the vote.